Preseason Top 10: Division 3
In this article:
Prep Hoops Wisconsin reveals our preseason top 10 in Division 3 ahead of the 2023-24 season...
1. MILWAUKEE ACADEMY OF SCIENCE
2022-23 Record: 18-7
WIAA Playoff Finish: Lost to West Salem in the state semifinals
Key Returners:
Devin Brown
Devin
Brown
6'7" | PF
Milwaukee Academy of Science | 2025
State
#196
Nation
WI
(21.6 ppg),
Jamarion Batemon
Jamarion
Batemon
6'3" | CG
Milwaukee Academy of Science | 2025
State
#174
Nation
WI
(20.5 ppg), Agape Keys. Jr. (11.2 ppg),
Elijah Thornton
Elijah
Thornton
6'7" | PF
Milwaukee Academy of Science | 2024
State
WI
(6.6 ppg),
Amare Jackson
Amare
Jackson
6'4" | SF
Milwaukee Academy of Science | 2025
State
WI
(4.7 ppg)
Notable Losses: Deshawn Webb (4.9 ppg)
The Novas have reached back-to-back state tournaments as very young teams. Now with some experience, MAS is the runaway favorite in Division 3 behind their two-headed monster of Brown and Batemon. The Novas also added sophomore guard
Deuce Burkes
Deuce
Burkes
6'2" | CG
Milwaukee Academy of Science | 2026
WI
, a transfer from Oak Creek, and one of the top players in the 2026 class. There's a lot of good role players on this roster too -- Keys Jr, Thornton, and Jackson -- who can carry them on off nights.
This evaluation is available to subscribers.
Is this you, Devin? Unlock your evaluation to everyone by subscribing
Highlights
2. SAINT THOMAS MORE
2022-23 Record: 23-5
WIAA Playoff Finish: Lost to Milwaukee Academy of Science in the sectional finals
Key Returners:
Amari McCottry
Amari
McCottry
6'5" | SF
St. Thomas More | 2024
State
#304
Nation
WI
(23.4 ppg),
Sekou Konneh
Sekou
Konneh
6'8" | SF
St. Thomas More | 2024
State
WI
(16.6 ppg),
Evan Oleson
Evan
Oleson
6'1" | SG
St. Thomas More | 2024
State
WI
(11.8 ppg),
Kenari Parr
Kenari
Parr
6'2" | SG/SF
St. Thomas More | 2025
State
WI
(6.1 ppg)
Notable Losses: N/A
STM gets its top five scorers back and features arguably the best frontcourt in Wisconsin via McCottry and Konneh, a pair of Division 1 prospects. The Cavaliers lost a heartbreaker to Milwaukee Academy of Science in last season's sectional final. They'll likely meet in this season's regionals. If STM is going to get back to Madison for the second time in three seasons, look for Parr to potentially make a nice jump.
This evaluation is available to subscribers.
Is this you, Amari? Unlock your evaluation to everyone by subscribing
Highlights
3. DOMINICAN
2022-23 Record: 17-9
WIAA Playoff Finish: Lost to Milwaukee Academy of Science in sectionals
Key Returners:
Aaron Womack
Aaron
Womack
6'6" | SF
Dominican | 2025
State
#228
Nation
WI
(19.3 ppg),
Markel Webb
Markel
Webb
6'2" | SG
Dominican | 2024
State
WI
(17.6 ppg),
Jaiden Martin
Jaiden
Martin
6'1" | CG
Dominican | 2024
State
WI
(16.4 ppg),
Derrick Johnson
Derrick
Johnson
6'3" | CG
Dominican | 2024
State
WI
(14.6 ppg), Kingston Caldwell (8.4 ppg)
Notable Losses: N/A
Just about everything is back for the Knights in 2023-24. Dominican returns its top 10 leading scorers from last season. This group has been together a very long time and is a real sleeper pick to emerge from Sectional 4. Unfortunately, this is yet another season in which we won't see the best four teams at the Kohl Center as Dominican would have to go through Carmen NW, St. Thomas More or Milwaukee Academy of Science. With their style of organized chaos combined with a lot of 3's, Dominican can beat anybody on any given night.
This evaluation is available to subscribers.
Is this you, Aaron? Unlock your evaluation to everyone by subscribing
Highlights
4. CARMEN NORTHWEST
2022-23 Record: 20-4
WIAA Playoff Finish: Lost to Dominican in regionals
Key Returners:
Dupree Fletcher Jr.
Dupree
Fletcher Jr.
5'10" | PG
Milwaukee Carmen | 2024
State
WI
(22.7 ppg),
Javante Edwards
Javante
Edwards
6'1" | SG
Carmen Northwest | 2025
State
WI
(13.8 ppg)
Notable Losses: Ta'Quorion Tribune (20.2 ppg), Amaree Posey (16.6 ppg)
Edwards and Fletcher are an explosive backcourt duo that can absolutely fill it up offensively. Both players are extremely dynamic and can eat defenses alive with the ball in their hands. The reigning Milwaukee City Gold champs lose some key pieces, but this will still be a very difficult team to beat in March.
This evaluation is available to subscribers.
Is this you, Dupree? Unlock your evaluation to everyone by subscribing
5. LAKE MILLS
2022-23 Record: 16-10
WIAA Playoff Finish: Lost to Lakeside Lutheran in regionals
Key Returners:
AJ Bender
AJ
Bender
6'3" | CG
Lake Mills | 2025
State
WI
(22.1 ppg),
Brady Benish
Brady
Benish
6'0" | SG
Lake Mills | 2026
State
WI
(11.7 ppg),
Ryan Horkan
Ryan
Horkan
6'1" | PG
Lake Mills | 2025
WI
(9.2 ppg), Matthew Stenbroten (9.0 ppg),
Notable Losses: Liam Carrigan (7.4 ppg)
Ignore the 16-10 record. The L-Cats played in a very tough conference last season, sharing the Capitol North league crown with two other teams. A young group last season, Lake Mills also started the year 6-6 before turning a corner in mid-January. Bender is one of the most explosive guards in the state and a do-it-all player who can put a team on his back. However, with the L-Cats returning their top four scorers from 2022-23, not sure there's many nights he'll have to do that.
Highlights
6. KIEL
2022-23 Record: 21-5
WIAA Playoff Finish: Lost to Brillion in regionals
Key Returners:
Pierce Arenz
Pierce
Arenz
5'10" | PG
Kiel | 2024
State
WI
(18.9 ppg),
Grant Manz
Grant
Manz
6'6" | SF
Kiel | 2024
State
WI
(12.2 ppg), Jack Heckmann (11.2 ppg), Braden April (10.5 ppg)
Notable Losses:
Thought this team was overlooked all season. In the same conference as Brillion, the eventual D3 state champs, Kiel was handed three of their five losses in that matchup alone. Aside from a hiccup against Chilton, the Raiders were very consistent. This group now gets its top six scorers back, including Arenz, who is one of the best guards in the state. Manz is also one of the most improved players in Wisconsin and is coming off a fantastic AAU season.
7. OOSTBURG
2022-23 Record: 18-7
WIAA Playoff Finish: Lost to Campbellsport in regionals
Key Returners:
JJ Zavatchin
JJ
Zavatchin
6'3" | SF
Oostburg | 2026
State
WI
(20.2 ppg), Cade Dirske (11.6 ppg)
Notable Losses: Lucas Stewart (8.8 ppg), Liam Stewart (7.3 ppg)
Oostburg won the Big East - South last season and was led by freshmen. With both Zavatchin and Dirske back and each having gone through a full season on varsity, the Flying Dutchmen could build on last season's 18-7 record, despite losing a good chunk of their core.
8. PRESCOTT
2022-23 Record: 21-6
WIAA Playoff Finish: Lost to Osceola in sectionals
Key Returners:
Dallas Wallin
Dallas
Wallin
6'3" | SF
Prescott | 2024
State
WI
(19.7 ppg)
Notable Losses: Jordan Malmov (23.9 ppg), Brandon Stuart (11.5 ppg), Brady Block (8.1 ppg)
Yes, Prescott lost a lot from last season's squad, which fell short of expectations. Malmov was one of the state's top scorers. The Cardinals lost three of their top four leaders in that department as well. But, when you have a do-it-all player like Wallin, who's capable of controlling the game as a point-wing and contributing across the board, you're going to be okay. Prescott has also won a minimum of 21 games in each of the last three seasons. This group knows how to win and will find some pieces.
This evaluation is available to subscribers.
Is this you, Dallas? Unlock your evaluation to everyone by subscribing
Highlights
9. BROOKFIELD ACADEMY
2022-23 Record: 18-7
WIAA Playoff Finish: Lost to Brown Deer in regionals
Key Returners:
Anthony Przybilla
Anthony
Przybilla
6'6" | SF
Brookfield Academy | 2024
State
WI
(18.4 ppg),
Nolan Demski
Nolan
Demski
6'4" | SG
Brookfield Academy | 2024
State
WI
(12.0 ppg),
Trent Rayborn
Trent
Rayborn
5'11" | CG
Brookfield Academy | 2024
State
WI
(11.8 ppg), Davis Arnold (9.9 ppg)
Notable Losses: Maliq Crawford (7.2 ppg)
Crawford, the team's point guard, might be a sneaky tough loss to overcome, but this Brookfield Academy squad is deep, experienced, and talented. Led by Przybilla, one of the state's consistently most improved players, the Blue Knights return their top four leading scorers. Playing in the Midwest Classic Conference, where they earned a share of the title in 2022-23, you know Brookfield Academy is going to be battle tested for March.
This evaluation is available to subscribers.
Is this you, Anthony? Unlock your evaluation to everyone by subscribing
10. EDGERTON
2022-23 Record: 17-9
WIAA Playoff Finish: Lost to Turner in regionals
Key Returners:
Olin Zellmer
Olin
Zellmer
6'0" | PG
Edgerton | 2025
State
WI
(16.0 ppg),
Leyton McKillips
Leyton
McKillips
5'11" | CG
Edgerton | 2024
WI
(15.9 ppg),
Preston Schaffner
Preston
Schaffner
6'3" | SG
Edgerton | 2024
State
WI
(12.0 ppg),
Jack Fox
Jack
Fox
6'1" | SG
Edgerton | 2025
State
WI
(8.1 ppg)
Notable Losses: Will Schuman (5.0 ppg)
The Rock Valley was absolutely loaded last season. Edgerton still found a way to finish third in a league that had five really good teams. The Crimson now reload with their top four scorers and feature a very balanced squad with a number of players who can lead them in scoring on any given night. Case in point, when a player like Schaffner is your third leading scorer, that's a nice luxury to have.
This evaluation is available to subscribers.
Is this you, Preston? Unlock your evaluation to everyone by subscribing
Highlights
Honorable Mention: Northwestern, Somerset, Freedom, Southern Door, Edgewood, Lake Country Lutheran, Elk Mound, Gale Ettrick-Trempealeau, Wautoma, Kettle Moraine Lutheran, Brillion, Turner, Racine St. Catherine's, Xavier, Platteville
Access all of Prep Hoops
Continue reading this article and every scouting report.