Game Report: Watertown Luther Prep 66, Columbus 57
In this article:
KEYS TO THE GAME
There is a reason why Watertown Luther Prep has won 20 of 23 games. The Phoenix are good. Really good. Coach Steve Vasold's club proved that Friday in a WIAA Division 3 regional semifinal before a raucous crowd in the Luther Prep gym. Despite not breaking into the state rankings for most of the season, Luther Prep controlled the lead for virtually the entire game and posted a convincing 66-57 victory over a Columbus squad that came into the game battle tested as a member of the Capitol North Conference. The Nottling brothers, Watertown residents who have been stellar all winter for Luther Prep, led the way with bouncy junior
Levi Nottling
Levi
Nottling
6'5" | PF/SF
Watertown Luther Prep | 2027
State
WI
netting 21 points and steady senior
Gabe Nottling
Gabe
Nottling
6'4" | PF/SF
Watertown Luther Prep | 2026
State
WI
adding 11. The Phoenix led 27-21 at intermission, extended its lead to 10 points midway through the second half and then withstood a couple of Columbus rallies to secure the win and a spot in the regional finals today at Lakeside Lutheran. Senior
Jonny Cotter
Jonny
Cotter
6'0" | PG
Columbus | 2026
State
WI
converted an old-school three-point play with 7:11 left to cut Luther Prep's lead to 44-42, but the Phoenix answered on the other end with senior Micah Kieselhorst completing his own three-point play. From that point, Columbus was chasing and although the Cardinals were never out of it, they also were unable to get over the hump. Cotter and senior
Peyton Powers
Peyton
Powers
6'2" | CG
Columbus | 2026
State
WI
each had 17 points to lead Columbus. Luther Prep's superior depth was a big factor in the contest as the Phoenix reserves outscored the Cardinal backups, 15-3.
GAME MVP
This evaluation is available to subscribers.
Is this you, Levi? Unlock your evaluation to everyone by subscribing
Highlights
EMERGING PLAYERS
This evaluation is available to subscribers.
Is this you, Gabe? Unlock your evaluation to everyone by subscribing
Highlights
This evaluation is available to subscribers.
Is this you, Jonas? Unlock your evaluation to everyone by subscribing
Highlights
This evaluation is available to subscribers.
Is this you, Peyton? Unlock your evaluation to everyone by subscribing
Highlights
THE BIG PICTURE
Columbus had its season end with an 18-8 record and a third-place finish in the Capitol North Conference at 6-4. The Cardinals started five seniors against Luther Prep and went seven deep with senior
Blake Carthew
Blake
Carthew
6'0" | CG
Columbus | 2026
WI
and freshman Sam Powers earning time off the bench. Although Columbus loses plenty to graduation, coach Jeff Downing's program figures to remain highly competitive behind a very strong freshmen class that includes Liam Riese and
Max Pederson
Max
Pederson
6'1" | PG
Columbus | 2029
WI
in addition to Sam Powers.
Luther Prep moves on to the regional finals to face a familiar foe and long-time rival in Lakeside Lutheran. The two squads met up in mid January with Lakeside Lutheran posting a 65-56 victory behind 21 points from senior
Wes Rahn
Wes
Rahn
6'8" | PF
Lakeside Lutheran | 2026
State
WI
. The winner of Saturday's regional finals advances to the sectional semifinals where it will play the winner of Lake Mills and East Troy.
BOXSCORE
Columbus (21-36 = 57)
Mobry 6, P. Powers 17, Hacht 8, Corrado 6, Cotter 17, S. Powers 3, Carthew 0. Three-point field goals: Hacht 2, P. Powers 1, Carrado 1, S. Powers 1. FT: 12-15. Fouled out: None. Record: 18-8.
Watertown Luther Prep (27-39 = 66)
G. Nottling 11, L. Nottling 21, Meyer 5, Kieselhorst 6, Fitzsimmons 8, Frick 7, Schultz 5, Kurbis 3. Three-point field goals: G. Nottling 2, Fitzsimmons 2, L. Nottling 1, Meyer 1, Kurbis 1. FT: 21-26. Fouled out: Meyer. Record: 20-3.
Access all of Prep Hoops
Continue reading this article and every scouting report.
