Preseason Top 10: Division 2
In this article:
Prep Hoops Wisconsin reveals our preseason top 10 teams in Division 2 heading into the 2023-24 season...
1. NICOLET
2022-23 Record: 24-5
WIAA Playoff Finish: Lost to Pewaukee in the state semifinals
Key Returners:
Davion Hannah
Davion
Hannah
6'5" | SF
Link Academy | 2025
#33
Nation
MO
(19.9 ppg),
David Bolden
David
Bolden
6'0" | PG
Nicolet | 2025
State
WI
(11.9 ppg), Rashad Davis (10.8 ppg),
Matthew McKay
Matthew
McKay
6'6" | SF
Nicolet | 2024
State
WI
(7.4 ppg)
Notable Losses: N/A
This might ruffle some feathers, but the fact of the matter is, Nicolet had Pewaukee beaten last season and never should have had to play that one in a semifinal. Milan Momcilovic took things over late and pushed the Pirates over the top as the Knights just couldn't match up with the 6-foot-9 forward. Momcilovic is now at Iowa State and Nicolet reloads with just about everything. The Knights were led by three underclassmen last season, including Hannah, who is arguably the state's best NBA prospect right now. A year older with a chip on their shoulder, Nicolet is very, very dangerous.
This evaluation is available to subscribers.
Is this you, Davion? Unlock your evaluation to everyone by subscribing
Highlights
2. PEWAUKEE
2022-23 Record: 27-3
WIAA Playoff Finish: Won the Division 2 State Championship
Key Returners:
Nick Janowski
Nick
Janowski
6'3" | SG
Pewaukee | 2024
State
#126
Nation
WI
(23.2 ppg),
Luka Momcilovic
Luka
Momcilovic
6'8" | PF
Pewaukee | 2025
State
WI
(8.4 ppg),
Isaiah Robinson
Isaiah
Robinson
6'1" | PG
Pewaukee | 2025
State
WI
(6.7 ppg),
Karson Osterman
Karson
Osterman
5'9" | PG
Pewaukee | 2025
State
WI
(6.5 ppg)
Notable Losses: Milan Momcilovic (23.6 ppg), Kaeden Osterman (5.1 ppg).
Can Janowski make it a four-peat? The Nebraska commit has never won the state championship during his three seasons at Pewaukee, but this will be his biggest test yet without Momcilovic by his side. The Pirates hope that
Luka Momcilovic
Luka
Momcilovic
6'8" | PF
Pewaukee | 2025
State
WI
and Robinson take some key steps forward after playing sizable, but complementary roles in 2022-23.
This evaluation is available to subscribers.
Is this you, Nick? Unlock your evaluation to everyone by subscribing
3. WISCONSIN LUTHERAN
2022-23 Record: 23-5
WIAA Playoff Finish: Lost to Pewaukee in the sectional finals
Key Returners:
Kon II Knueppel
Kon
II Knueppel
6'6" | SG
Wisconsin Lutheran | 2024
State
#15
Nation
WI
(19.7 ppg),
Logan Rindfleisch
Logan
Rindfleisch
6'5" | SF
Wisconsin Lutheran | 2024
State
WI
(6.1 ppg),
Grayson Young
Grayson
Young
6'2" | CG
Wisconsin Lutheran | 2024
State
WI
(4.5 ppg)
Notable Losses: Jamiir Allen (13.4 ppg), Prentice Young (12.5 ppg), Landon Key (9.5 ppg)
The moment Wisconsin Lutheran has waited for is finally here -- Pewaukee is out of Sectional 4. Not that the Vikings shy away from the challenge, but the state tournament has not featured arguably the best two teams in the state for that reason. Knueppel, a Duke commit, will likely have to be unleashed this season. The losses of Allen, Key, and Young should not overlooked, likely forcing Knueppel to really up his shot intake as a senior. If Wisco can get big jumps from Rindfleisch, Young, and maybe sophomore
Zavier Zens
Zavier
Zens
6'7" | SF
Wisconsin Lutheran | 2026
State
WI
, they're one of 3-4 teams that can hoist the gold ball in March.
This evaluation is available to subscribers.
Is this you, Kon? Unlock your evaluation to everyone by subscribing
Highlights
4. WAUWATOSA WEST
2022-23 Record: 18-8
WIAA Playoff Finish: Lost to Pius XI in regionals
Key Returners:
Kai Rogers
Kai
Rogers
6'10" | C
Overtime Elite | 2025
#41
Nation
WI
(15.8 ppg),
Jake Hansen
Jake
Hansen
6'1" | SG
Wauwatosa West | 2025
State
#331
Nation
WI
(15.0 ppg),
Moses Long
Moses
Long
6'3" | SG
Wauwatosa West | 2024
State
WI
(6.2 ppg)
Notable Losses: Cole Hansen (18.0 ppg)
The Trojans won a share of the Greater Metro Conference for the first time in school history last winter. Leading scorer Cole Hansen has transferred, leaving somewhat of a void, but there's still plenty left in the cupboard. Rogers and
Jake Hansen
Jake
Hansen
6'1" | SG
Wauwatosa West | 2025
State
#331
Nation
WI
are one of the top 3-4 best inside-outside duos in the state. West also picked up some pieces, including a freshman, that might make this group deeper than it was a year ago -- certainly bigger and more athletic.
This evaluation is available to subscribers.
Is this you, Kai? Unlock your evaluation to everyone by subscribing
Highlights
5. WHITNALL
2022-23 Record: 25-4
WIAA Playoff Finish: Lost to Pewaukee in the state championship game
Key Returners:
Jack Lutz
Jack
Lutz
6'0" | SG
Whitnall | 2025
State
WI
(17.3 ppg),
Myles Herro
Myles
Herro
6'3" | PG
Whitnall | 2025
State
#237
Nation
WI
(6.3 ppg)
Notable Losses: Austin Herro (14.8 ppg), Nate Baake (7.6 ppg), Ethan Thomas (6.9 ppg)
Whitnal won't be nearly as deep as they were last season, but the reigning Woodland East champs have one of the top backcourt in the state. Lutz is coming off a breakout sophomore campaign. Herro, who is one of the state's top facilitators and floor generals, will be able to provide more of an offensive lift that his brother leaves behind.
This evaluation is available to subscribers.
Is this you, Jack? Unlock your evaluation to everyone by subscribing
Highlights
6. STOUGHTON
2022-23 Record: 19-8
WIAA Playoff Finish: Lost to McFarland in sectionals
Key Returners:
Ty Fernholz
Ty
Fernholz
6'2" | SG
Stoughton | 2024
State
WI
(20.7 ppg),
Sawyer Schipper
Sawyer
Schipper
6'1" | SG
Stoughton | 2024
State
WI
(14.2 ppg),
Jay Johnson
Jay
Johnson
6'4" | SF
Stoughton | 2025
State
WI
(6.8 ppg),
Carter Sullivan
Carter
Sullivan
6'6" | PF
Stoughton | 2025
State
WI
(6.8 ppg),
Jacob Hibner
Jacob
Hibner
6'3" | SG
Stoughton | 2026
State
WI
(6.0 ppg)
Notable Losses: N/A
I like the makeup of this group. Stoughton has a little bit of senior leadership and some upside, sprinkled in with some youth. The Vikings get their top six scorers back from a season ago, including the Michigan Tech commit Fernholz. There's a few under the radar prospects on this team as well, including Schipper, who's a strong secondary scorer and can slow down a lot of team's best guard.
This evaluation is available to subscribers.
Is this you, Ty? Unlock your evaluation to everyone by subscribing
7. ONALASKA
2022-23 Record: 19-6
WIAA Playoff Finish: Lost to La Crosse Central in regionals
Key Returners: Evan Anderson (18.8 ppg),
Isaac Skemp
Isaac
Skemp
6'4" | SF
Onalaska | 2024
State
WI
(8.8 ppg), Adam Skifton (6.8 ppg)
Notable Losses: T.J. Stuttley (16.3 ppg)
The loss of Stuttley, who transferred to Link Academy, will be tough to overcome and really cuts into the ceiling of this team. However, it's still Onalaska -- a tough, blue collar program that's rarely going to beat itself. Anderson broke out as a junior and cemented himself as one of the state's top players. Skemp appears to have made a nice jump and turned himself into more than just a spot-up 3-point shooter. The Hilltoppers will find guys down the roster as well, like Skifton, who do the dirty work and set a tone.
8. FOX VALLEY LUTHERAN
2022-23 Record: 22-4
WIAA Playoff Finish: Lost to New London in regionals
Key Returners:
Adam Loberger
Adam
Loberger
6'4" | SG
Fox Valley Lutheran | 2024
State
WI
(17.2 ppg),
Sam Ferge
Sam
Ferge
6'4" | PG
Fox Valley Lutheran | 2024
State
WI
(13.2 ppg)
Notable Losses: Nick Kraftzenk (9.3 ppg), Jackson Papendorf (8.9 ppg)
The reigning North Eastern Conference champs got tripped up way too early in the playoffs last season, seeing their 13-game winning streak snapped in the regional finals. There's some tough losses to overcome, but FVL gets its top two scorers back and both are seniors. This is a group that was untouched for much of the 2022-23 campaign and knows how win, collecting 17 wins by double digits. The Foxes were also 5-1 in games decided by five points or less.
This evaluation is available to subscribers.
Is this you, Adam? Unlock your evaluation to everyone by subscribing
9. ASHWAUBENON
2022-23 Record: 15-10
WIAA Playoff Finish: Lost to Notre Dame in regionals
Key Returners:
Drew Tomashek
Drew
Tomashek
6'0" | PG
Ashwaubenon | 2024
State
WI
(14.2 ppg),
Jayden Schoen
Jayden
Schoen
6'3" | SG
Ashwaubenon | 2024
State
WI
(13.4 ppg), Jackson Sims (11.7 ppg),
Notable Losses: Zach Kelly (10.2 ppg)
With the Fox River Classic Conference losing A LOT of talent, think you see Ashwaubenon drastically improve on its record. The Jaguars return three of their top four scorers from last season, including Schoen and Tomashek who have been playing together for three years now. Each has taken sizable steps forward during their high school career. No reason to think that won't happen again this winter.
This evaluation is available to subscribers.
Is this you, Drew? Unlock your evaluation to everyone by subscribing
10. MOUNT HOREB
2022-23 Record: 16-10
WIAA Playoff Finish: Lost to Stoughton in regionals
Key Returners:
Josh Manchester
Josh
Manchester
6'4" | SG
Mount Horeb | 2026
State
WI
(17.3 ppg), Nick Vorwold (10.5 ppg),
Zach Maguire
Zach
Maguire
6'4" | SG/SF
Mount Horeb | 2025
State
WI
(8.1 ppg), Austin Leibfried
Notable Losses: Rocco Richie
The Vikings were fairly young last season, but shook things up with big wins against the likes of Onalaska, Stoughton, and Burlington. They were also one possession away from advancing to sectionals. Manchester had one of the best freshman seasons that nobody was talking about. Most of the core is back from last season and there's a little bit of everything on this roster.
This evaluation is available to subscribers.
Is this you, Josh? Unlock your evaluation to everyone by subscribing
Highlights
Honorable Mention: River Falls, Grafton, La Crosse Central, West De Pere, Mosinee, West Salem, Plymouth, Monona Grove, Pius XI, Burlington
Access all of Prep Hoops
Continue reading this article and every scouting report.