Badger Small Preview

In this article:
2023-24 Final Standings
1. Stoughton 14-0 (24-4); 2. Mount Horeb 12-2 (21-6); 3. Sauk Prairie 8-6 (12-13); 4. McFarland 7-7 (9-15); 5. Baraboo 6-8 (17-9); 6. Edgewood 4-10 (5-20); 6. Reedsburg 4-10 (8-18); 8. Portage 1-13 (7-19).
2024-25 Picks
1. Stoughton --The Vikings ran roughshod over the competition in the Badger Small a year ago and might do the same this time around despite losing three starters to graduation. Junior
Jacob Hibner
Jacob
Hibner
6'3" | SG
Stoughton | 2026
State
WI
(6-3, 10.5 ppg, 3.3 rpg) had a breakout off season while competing with the
Wisconsin Academy
club program and picked up multiple NCAA Division 2 scholarship offers. Senior
Carter Sullivan
Carter
Sullivan
6'6" | PF
Stoughton | 2025
State
WI
(6-6, 8.0 ppg, 5.1 rpg) gives the Vikings size in the post while seniors
Jay Johnson
Jay
Johnson
6'4" | SF
Stoughton | 2025
State
WI
(6-3, 3.2 ppg, 2.3 rpg) and LeShawn Brown (6-2, 3.5 ppg, 2.6 rpg) along with junior Ethan Zywicki (6-1, 3.4 ppg, 2.2 rpg) provide solid overall size and athleticism.
2. Mount Horeb -- Another 20-plus win season is certainly a possibility for Mount Horeb, which went 21-6 a year ago and welcomes back four starters. Junior sharpshooter
Josh Manchester
Josh
Manchester
6'4" | SG
Mount Horeb | 2026
State
WI
(6-3, 24.6 ppg, 5.0 rpg) leads the way for coach Todd Nesheim's squad. Manchester ranks among the elite scorers in the state and is receiving strong interest from a number of NCAA Division I programs. Joining Manchester as returning regulars are seniors
Zach Maguire
Zach
Maguire
6'4" | SG/SF
Mount Horeb | 2025
State
WI
(6-4, 9.0 ppg, 5.8 rpg), Chris Kiel (5-10, 1.7 ppg, 1.9 rpg) and
Griffin Hannah
Griffin
Hannah
6'3" | SG/SF
Mount Horeb | 2025
State
WI
(6-0, 4.1 ppg, 4.1 rpg).
3. McFarland -- The Spartans enjoy an abundance of size within their program as senior
Ben Forbes
Ben
Forbes
6'9" | PF
McFarland | 2025
State
WI
(6-9, 6.4 ppg, 5.9 rpg), senior Brady Ochalla (6-4, 7.0 ppg, 4.3 rpg) and sophomore
Eli Krueger
Eli
Krueger
6'9" | PF
McFarland | 2027
State
WI
(6-8, 9.4 ppg, 7.5 rpg) all figure to play key roles for coach Jeff Meinholdt. In the backcourt, McFarland will count heavily on returning starters Hayden Harrison (6-0, 4.9 ppg, 2.5 rpg) and Mason Roe (6-2, 4.3 ppg, 3.3 rpg).
4. Sauk Prairie -- Sauk Prairie could be the surprise team in the Badger Small as coach Sean McCann brings back a quick team that boasts good perimeter shooting skill.
Nicholas Keyser
Nicholas
Keyser
6'1" | PG
Sauk Prairie | 2025
State
WI
(6-1, 11.3 ppg, 4.5 rpg) and
Otis Andres
Otis
Andres
5'11" | CG
Sauk Prairie | 2026
State
WI
(5-10, 3.8 ppg) are returning starters while senior Casey Brickl (6-5) and sophomore
Brendan Marquardt
Brendan
Marquardt
6'5" | PF
Sauk Prairie | 2027
State
WI
(6-5) likely will play key roles on the frontline.
5. Edgewood -- Long-time assistant Kevin Schmotzer takes over the permanent head-coaching duties at Edgewood after serving as interim coach for the final 19 games last year. He has a talented backcourt duo to work with as sophomore
Timmy West
Timmy
West
6'1" | CG
Madison Edgewood | 2027
WI
(6-1, 11.4 ppg, 5.8 rpg) and junior
Gannon Bagstad
Gannon
Bagstad
6'1" | PG
Edgewood | 2026
State
WI
(6-1, 5.5 ppg, 2.1 rpg) started on last year's squad.
6. Reedsburg -- The Beavers have an experienced trio in the backcourt with seniors Danny Pickle (6-3, 12.2 ppg, 6.8 rpg), Alek Southworth (6-2, 9.4 ppg, 2.6 rpg) and Bo Bestor (5-11, 7.5 ppg) all returning to the starting lineup. Coach Ty Horkan is concerned about interior defense and rebounding, but some young players could help in those areas, including junior Joan Williams (6-4) and freshman
Ian McClure
Ian
McClure
6'3" | SF
Reedsburg | 2028
WI
(6-3).
7. Portage -- Rookie coach Caleb Bohrer is worried about the lack of varsity experience at Portage, but he isn't all that troubled about his defense as he feels the Warriors' quickness and strength will be assets on that end of the court. Senior
Elias Vera
Elias
Vera
6'3" | SG
Portage | 2025
WI
(6-3, 13.3 ppg, 5.0 rpg) is the lone returning starter at Portage, but senior Aidan Warfield (6-6, 3.8 ppg, 2.5 rpg) earned plenty of playing time as a reserve in 2023-24.
8. Baraboo -- The Thunderbirds return one of the league's most experienced and talented backcourt players in senior
Alex Hannagan
Alex
Hannagan
6'2" | CG
Baraboo | 2025
State
WI
(6-2, 10.8 ppg, 4.7 rpg), but depth. lack of size and overall experience all are major concerns for coach Tyler Fish.
Top Returning Scorers
Josh Manchester
Josh
Manchester
6'4" | SG
Mount Horeb | 2026
State
WI
, Mount Horeb (24.6 ppg)
Elias Vera
Elias
Vera
6'3" | SG
Portage | 2025
WI
, Portage (13.3 ppg)
Danny Pickle, Reedsburg (12.2 ppg)
Timmy West
Timmy
West
6'1" | CG
Madison Edgewood | 2027
WI
, Edgewood (11.4 ppg)
Nicholas Keyser
Nicholas
Keyser
6'1" | PG
Sauk Prairie | 2025
State
WI
, Sauk Prairie (11.3 ppg)
Alex Hannagan
Alex
Hannagan
6'2" | CG
Baraboo | 2025
State
WI
, Baraboo (10.8 ppg)
Jacob Hibner
Jacob
Hibner
6'3" | SG
Stoughton | 2026
State
WI
, Stoughton (10.5 ppg)
Projected All-Conference Teams
First Team
Jacob Hibner
Jacob
Hibner
6'3" | SG
Stoughton | 2026
State
WI
, 6-3, Jr., Stoughton
Josh Manchester
Josh
Manchester
6'4" | SG
Mount Horeb | 2026
State
WI
, 6-3, Jr., Mount Horeb
Eli Krueger
Eli
Krueger
6'9" | PF
McFarland | 2027
State
WI
, 6-8, Soph., McFarland
Timmy West
Timmy
West
6'1" | CG
Madison Edgewood | 2027
WI
, 6-1, Soph., Edgewood
Carter Sullivan
Carter
Sullivan
6'6" | PF
Stoughton | 2025
State
WI
, 6-6, Sr., Stoughton
Second Team
Elias Vera
Elias
Vera
6'3" | SG
Portage | 2025
WI
, 6-3, Sr., Portage
Zach Maguire
Zach
Maguire
6'4" | SG/SF
Mount Horeb | 2025
State
WI
, 6-4, Sr., Mount Horeb
Nicholas Keyser
Nicholas
Keyser
6'1" | PG
Sauk Prairie | 2025
State
WI
, 6-1, Sr., Sauk Prairie
Danny Pickle, 6-3, Sr., Reedsburg
Alex Hannagan
Alex
Hannagan
6'2" | CG
Baraboo | 2025
State
WI
, 6-2, Sr., Baraboo
The Big Five
Best Shooter:
Josh Manchester
Josh
Manchester
6'4" | SG
Mount Horeb | 2026
State
WI
, Mount Horeb
Best Rebounder:
Eli Krueger
Eli
Krueger
6'9" | PF
McFarland | 2027
State
WI
, McFarland
Best Defender:
Jay Johnson
Jay
Johnson
6'4" | SF
Stoughton | 2025
State
WI
, Stoughton
Best Collegiate Prospect:
Josh Manchester
Josh
Manchester
6'4" | SG
Mount Horeb | 2026
State
WI
, Mount Horeb
Most Improved Player: Alex Chapman, Mount Horeb
Access all of Prep Hoops
Continue reading this article and more.
Continue Reading