The athletic wing/forward was really good on both ends of the floor for Indiana Jammers 17u in Friday night’s loss. He’s a physical prospect that knows how to use his body to his advantage. Has improving perimeter skills to go along with his high motor around the basket. Capable shooter from the perimeter with the ability to put the ball on the floor. Big time rebounder and versatile defender that will do whatever it takes to get his team a win.

One of the most athletic players I saw all weekend, Tolliver was playing above the rim early and often, throwing down dunks attacking off the baseline, on alley-oops, off cuts and in transition off steals. Whenever Tolliver had a clear launch area to the rim, he was throwing it down with authority. Another available 2026 prospect, I’d be focusing on how well rounded his offensive game is with the Indiana Jammers the next time I get to see Tolliver this spring. Lots of athletic upside with Tolliver and I also was impressed by his motor as well. Could be an interesting developmental swing for up-tempo programs.

Preston Tolliver Preston Tolliver 6'4" | SF Evansville Reitz | 2026 State IN is playing as well as anybody in the Southwest Indiana area. His combination of speed, size, and athleticism makes him a tough cover for most teams. The 6’6” Senior Forward plays with a high motor on both ends of the floor and impacts the game in the paint. High level rebounder and possesses a soft touch around the basket. Shooting a team best 37% from 3 on just 19 attempts on the season, he knows where his bread and butter is and he’s sticking to it and has dominated in every game that I’ve seen him play.

Preston Tolliver Preston Tolliver 6'4" | SF Evansville Reitz | 2026 State IN had the best overall performance at Hatchet House Hysteria in his teams 60-56 loss to Decatur Central. The athletic Senior Forward is an absolute load on the block with his strength and athleticism. He possesses good hands that catches everything and once he gets the ball, he knows what to do with it. Down low he makes quick, decisive moves to the basket where he looks to finish above the rim every chance he gets. Defensively he’s aggressive at the top of the Reitz zone with his length. In man to man he can guard multiples positions while doing a good job staying out of foul trouble.

This under-the-radar unsigned senior forward is a very intriguing small college prospect. At 6’5”, Tolliver has the necessary size and length to rebound and guard larger opponents while also possessing the athleticism and foot speed to matchup with guards. He can guard 1-4 at the next level. Tolliver led Evansville Reitz with 17 points, 5 rebounds, and 2 blocked shots against Brebuef Jesuit. He had 15 points, 3 rebounds, 2 assists, and 2 blocks in their morning loss to Noblesville.

An under-the-radar senior prospect down in Evansville, Tolliver posted a double-double of 24 points, 10 rebounds, and 4 blocked shots on Friday night. Evansville Reitz defeated Evansville Mater Dei 55-39.

We’ve seen Tolliver pull in several small college/JUCO offers over the last few months and he has a chance to play his way into more during his senior season at Evansville Reitz. As the only real returning contributor, he will be relied heavily upon to have a breakout season. The 6’4″ wing certainly has the physical makeup and skill set to do just that. He was impressive over the summer at the Charlie Hughes Showcase and should become a go-to threat for Reitz this season.

The athletic wing/forward out of Evansville Reitz has had a big summer with Craig Porter Elite and stayed steady with his performance at the UIndy Elite Camp. High motor wing that plays hard on both ends of the floor. Offensively he’s expanding his game. Excellent finisher around the basket that can play above the rim. Versatile defender that guards all over the floor. Good rebounder outside of his and defends the basket without fouling.