Game Report: Middleton 72, Verona 70 (OT)
In this article:
KEYS TO THE GAME
What started out as a rugby game on a basketball court turned into one of the more exciting and emotional games of the season. Although the physicality of the Middleton at Verona game lasted pretty much from opening tip until the last shot in overtime, the effort and determination of both teams also was evident throughout. In the end, Middleton hung on for an important 72-70 triumph after a potential game-winning three-point shot from Verona's
Owen Ayite-Atayi
Owen
Ayite-Atayi
6'3" | SG
Verona | 2026
State
WI
rimmed out as time ran out. The Cardinals moved into first place in the Big Eight Conference standings with the triumph while Verona slipped a game behind with one league setback. Middleton's relentless pressure from endline to endline throughout the entire 40 minutes of the contest paid dividends for coach Kevin Bavery's squad, now 9-1 on the campaign. Some key turnovers by Verona helped Middleton maintain a lead for most of the second half and overtime. But credit Verona's never-say-die attitude and the stellar all-around play of Ayite-Atayi for keeping the game in doubt until the very end. Ayite-Atayi finished with a game-high 32 points and he came oh-so-close to netting 35 and delivering a last-second victory to the Wildcats.
STAR OF THE GAME
This evaluation is available to subscribers.
Is this you, Owen? Unlock your evaluation to everyone by subscribing
Highlights
EMERGING PLAYERS
Part of a tireless backcourt that also includes Andrew Qastin Andrew Qastin 5'10" | PG Middleton | 2026 State WI and Jackson Guerrero Jackson Guerrero 6'0" | PG/CG Middleton | 2026 State WI , Grimes is a steady combination guard with a soft shooting touch, the ability to get to the basket with his speed and a defensive mindset to make things tough on opponents. Grimes finished with 11 points and hit a big three-point shot late in the triumph over Verona. He also split a pair of foul shots to give Middleton a 72-70 lead with under 10 seconds to play. Grimes is averaging 14.6 ppg for Middleton and has 27 three-point baskets in 10 games.
Highlights
Parks' ability to finish plays near the basket is vitally important for Middleton, making it difficult for the opposition to put too much defensive emphasis on just stopping the Cardinals' stellar guards. Parks had 16 points for Middleton in the win over Verona and his ability to provide a physical defensive presence in the lane on the other end made it tough for Verona to finish in the paint. Parks can attack the basket from the wing or on a dive to the hoop while also having the ability to play and score with his back to the basket.
Highlights
A smooth wing who launches from deep with confidence, Guerrero will play baseball at the next level for UW-La Crosse. But he also excels on the basketball court, particularly on defense where is he closing in on the school's all-time steals record. Guerrero hit back-to-back deep jump shots late in regulation to give Middleton a 53-47 lead with just six minutes left. He finished the game with a team-best 17 points while also teaming with fellow guards
Andrew Qastin
Andrew
Qastin
5'10" | PG
Middleton | 2026
State
WI
and
John Grimes
John
Grimes
6'0" | PG
Middleton | 2026
State
WI
to put extreme defensive pressure on the Verona guards.
Highlights
With
Will Stremlow
Will
Stremlow
6'4" | SG
Verona | 2027
State
WI
sidelined for a few extended periods due to foul issues, Jonjak came off the bench to provide a lift for Verona. The lanky 6-foot-2 wing scored eight points on four baskets for coach Cutrel Robinson's squad. He was a big part of strong bench play for the Wildcats that also included contributions from
Eli Andres
Eli
Andres
6'2" | SG/PG
Verona | 2026
WI
(six points) and
Max Crimmings
Max
Crimmings
6'5" | PF/SF
Verona | 2028
State
WI
(two points). Jonjak's combination of size and skill figure to be big assets for Verona over the next year and half.
Highlights
THE BIG PICTURE
Middleton took over first place in the Big Eight Conference standings and is the lone unbeaten team in league play at 7-0. The Cardinals, now 9-1 overall, return to league play Saturday with a 7:00 p.m. contest against Madison West at Madison La Follette.
Verona slipped to 6-1 in the conference and 8-2 in all games with the emotional loss to Middleton. The Wildcats also play Saturday at Madison La Follette, taking on Janesville Craig at 3:00 p.m.
COACH'S COMMENTS
From Middleton coach Kevin Bavery:
"I think to play the way we play involves a lot of trust between players and coaches. The commitment to be in pressure all the time isn't easy. Some 80 to 90 percent of our practice, even the night before a game, is in transition. We have to give a lot of freedom to our guys and it's high risk/reward, but we wouldn't do it any other way. Verona plays with a lot of similarities so neither team had to worry about pace."
BOXSCORE
Middleton (27-35-10 = 72)
Guerrero 17, Sheehan 10, Qaustin 13, Grimes 11, Parks 16, Passaglia 0, Breunig 3, Russell 0, Carlson 0, Klein 2. Three-point field goals: Guerrero 3, Qaustin 2, Grimes 2, Breunig 1, Sheehan 1. FT: 11-17. Fouled out: None. Record: 9-1.
Verona (26-36-8 = 70)
Connor 6, Ayite-Atayi 32, Stremlow 9, Jackson 2, Boado 5, Crimmings 2, Andres 6, Phillips 0, Jonjak 8. Three-point field goals: Ayite-Atayi 2, Stremlow 1, Andres 1. FT: 12-15. Fouled out: Stremlow. Record: 8-2.
Access all of Prep Hoops
Continue reading this article and every scouting report.